HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning and Zoning Commission-Minutes-11/9/2009~> ~~. City Hall
,~ =~- City of Col leyvil le 100 Main Street
~,~
~~~ ? 1~~, Colleyville, Texas 76034
Minutes -Final 817.503.1000
"~~'° www.colleyville.com
Planning and Zoning Commission
Monday, November 9, 2009 6:15 PM City Council Chambers
6:15 P.M.- PRE-COMMISSION WORKSHOP
EXECUTIVE CONFERENCE ROOM, THIRD FLOOR
LEGAL BRIEFING BY CITY ATTORNEY REGARDING PLANNING, ZONING,
PLATTING, AND LAND USE
REVIEW OF REGULAR AGENDA ITEMS
DISCUSSION OF PREVIOUS MEETING MINUTES
7:00 P.M.
REGULAR MEETING
1. CALL TO ORDER
The Planning and Zoning Commission meeting of the City of Colleyville
was called to order by Chairman Byerly on November 9, 2009, at 7:11
p.m.
2. ROLL CALL
Present: Commissioners Larry Knox, Dave Dudziak, Scott Redfearn,
Michael Clardy, Ron Rotthaus, David Phelps and Jeff Byerly
Staff Present: Jennifer Fadden, Ron Ruthven, Jeremy Hutt, Rob
McKeown, Kelly Cooper, Mona Gandy and Amy Shelley
3. INVOCATION
The invocation was given by Commissioner Knox.
4. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Commissioner Redfearn moved to approve the October 12, 2009
meeting minutes with the corrections to page 4, paragraph 6, to add
Ruthven after the statement made by Mr. Ron Ruthven and on page 5,
paragraph 3 to include the statement that the friendly amendment was
not accepted in the motion. Commissioner Phelps seconded.
City of Colleyvil/e Page 1 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final
November 9, 2009
The motion carried by the following vote:
Aye: 7 -Knox, Dudziak, Redfearn, Clardy, Rotthaus, Phelps, Byerly
6. CITIZEN COMMENTS REGARDING ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA
None
7. PUBLIC HEARING AGENDA ITEMS
7a Approval of a request for a Special Use Permit for a gas well site on 53.2
acres in the Hall Medlin and William E. Crooks Surveys located at 7612
Pleasant Run Road, Case ZC09-011
Commissioners Byerly and Knox recused themselves from this item and
Commissioner Dudziak chaired the meeting.
Ron Ruthven presented the case and briefed the Commissioners.
Commissioner Phelps questioned staff regarding if the 1,000 foot waiver
is the only item in conflict with the current code? Ron Ruthven replied
correct.
Commissioner Phelps questioned staff regarding if the other items or
additional conditions stated in the draft ordinance are in compliance with
the current code or above and beyond what the code requires? Ron
Ruthven replied a couple are in compliance with the code and others are
above and beyond, in addition to, what is required by the code.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned staff regarding if the 1,000 foot
requirement would cover the residence, the two barns and the garage?
Ron Ruthven replied correct.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned staff regarding if the draft language
prohibits any further construction within the 1,000 foot requirement? Ron
Ruthven replied the draft ordinance contains no language prohibiting
further construction however, Chapter 3.1 would prohibit the construction
of any new structures given the separation requirements in the
ordinance. He stated the Commission may choose, as an addition to the
approval, language could be added to the draft ordinance that would
prohibit any new structures to be built within a certain radius of the gas
well site.
Commissioner Phelps stated this land could be used for future
development and he stated not wanting this land to have an ordinance
written so that it could not be developed in the future, an ordinance too
harsh for the developer. He stated there would be risks involved with
developing this land. He questioned whether or not this is the best use
City of Col/eyville Page 2 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final
November 9, 2009
for this land. Ron Ruthven recommended that if the Commission did not
want to prohibit any future development from being built within a 1,000
feet of the gas well site, the language would need to be added to the
draft ordinance to reflect that recommendation.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned staff regarding if the noise and air
quality testings will be done by a certified inspector and what standards
will be used to make sure the community feels safe? Ron Ruthven
replied that Chapter 3.1 actually states how the noise level testing will be
done. He stated as far as who will be doing the testing, they will be
required to be experts and certified professionals in their fields. He
stated they will be third party inspectors hired by the applicant.
Commissioner Rotthaus questioned Fire Marshal Rob McKeown
regarding if he has any concerns with this SUP request? Rob McKeown
replied having a few concerns only because this is new to him. He
stated for the most part gas well drilling is safe, however, they have to
prepare for the worst. He stated having concerns about the residence
being within the 1,000 feet.
Commissioner Phelps questioned Rob McKeown if the fire department is
equipped to handle this type of situation? Rob McKeown stated there
are experts in the field for putting out this type of and magnitude of fire.
He stated they may have to call in overtime to cover a significant issue.
Commissioner Rotthaus questioned Rob McKeown if since the facility
will be gated, will there be a code system or gate key code to allow for
access? Rob McKeown stated the gas well company will have someone
at the gate to let you in, to sign you in. He stated they will be required to
put in a Knox box system to allow for emergency access.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned Rob McKeown if a complete concrete
driveway is necessary for access? Rob McKeown stated there is a need
for the complete driveway. He stated he believes the trucks they will be
using may be heavier than the fire apparatus the city has. He stated the
all weather service will help with these loads.
Commissioner Clardy questioned staff regarding if it would be possible to
plat only the pad site and not the entire property? Ron Ruthven replied
the pad site alone would not meet the minimum requirements of the
zoning district which requires a minimum amount of frontage along
Pleasant Run Road.
Mr. Aric Head, 777 Main Street, Suite 17, Fort Worth, representing
Jacobs Engineering Group, came forward to present the case and brief
the Commissioners.
City of Colleyvil/e Page 3 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final November 9, 2009
Commissioner Phelps questioned Mr. Head regarding why the testing
within a mile radius may not provide any real data. Mr. Head stated
testing should occur on the pad site not within a mile radius. He stated
they would like to discuss that with an environmental engineer with how
they will conduct the testing. He stated once this information goes into
the ordinance, it may limit the ability of the engineer for doing the proper
testing.
Commissioner Phelps questioned Mr. Head regarding what is the impact
of the 24 hour drilling, will it be intrusive to the neighbors? Mr. Head
replied it would be designed around the 65 decibel level rating.
Commissioner Phelps questioned Mr. Head regarding is there a
difference in the noise levels at night time versus during the day? Mr.
Head replied the ordinance is not specific to the achievement of the 65
level and mitigation for those levels can be achieved. Commissioner
Phelps stated the noise is for little or no intrusion during the night time.
Commissioner Phelps questioned Mr. Head regarding if there are any
examples of sites that do not require 24 hour drilling? Mr. Head replied
there are not any within the Barnett Shale.
Commissioner Clardy questioned Mr. Head regarding what is the rational
regarding this site as opposed to south; this would eliminate the distance
from the Southlake properties. Mr. Head replied any further south of the
residence, you would be within 1,000 feet of a Colleyville residence. He
stated this location has the least effect on the property owner's
residence.
Commissioner Clardy questioned regarding if the CORPS of Engineers
have been contacted regarding encroaching the flood plain? Mr. Head
replied we have done an environmental delineation. He stated any
impact to the flood plain is reviewed by city staff and then by FEMA.
Commissioner Clardy questioned staff regarding what are the
construction materials for the retaining wall within the flood plain area?
Mr. Head replied concrete or rock material. He stated staff has
recommended stone. He stated this will have the smallest impact to the
trees.
Commissioner Clardy questioned Mr. Head regarding what is the
standard height of the production platform when the rig is in operation?
Chris Hammack, Vice President for Titan Operating Drilling stated the
derricks do vary in size. He stated 137 feet is normal but there are some
that go up to 157 feet. Commissioner Clardy questioned Mr. Hammack
regarding the production platform, how tall is it? Mr. Hammack replied
the rig floor is 20 feet off the ground. Mr. Hammack stated they would
City of Colleyville Page 4 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final
November 9, 2009
come forward with a full sound abatement plan that specifically looks at
this drilling unit. He stated they would be using an electric rig whereas
others use generators.
Commissioner Rotthaus questioned Mr. Head regarding the change in
the material in the driveway, is that an economic request or a specific
reason for the change? Mr. Head stated if the property is developed in
the future, the removal of the concrete will be at the expense of the
developer; he stated the weight of the trucks, gravel versus concrete
does not make a difference. He stated they can mitigate for the dust by
using several products to control the dust. Commissioner Rotthaus
stated the future development of this property should not be a
consideration for the materials used seeing how this driveway will be in
use for a period of several years to come.
Commissioner Rotthaus questioned staff regarding what is the reason
for the platting of this property? Ron Ruthven stated platting allows for
all exactions, right of way, easements and so forth, to be given to the city
as part of the development. He stated platting takes land as a metes
and bounds description and added to the official documents of the
county. He stated platting helps with good site planning.
Commissioner Clardy questioned Mr. Head regarding the landscaping,
will the ones along the perimeter of the fence be put in at the start? Mr.
Head replied once the drilling is in place, usually about 60 to 90 days so
that anything that is involved in the drilling is gone, the permanent
landscaping will be installed. He stated Titan could plant everything at
once, but they prefer to plant last.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned Mr. Hammack regarding how long
the various stages will last? Mr. Hammack replied about 30 days, per
well, with the drilling of 2 to 4 wells at one time, in clusters. He stated
there are certain limits for drilling because of water limitations.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned Mr. Hammack regarding if they
would be drilled simultaneously or back to back? Mr. Hammack replied
back to back. He stated there would only be one derrick on the site at
any time, the 150 feet tall structure.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned Mr. Hammack regarding how long
between drilling that the fracturing will start? Mr. Hammac replied they
will commence within a week or two, with the fracturing lasting one week
per well. He stated this will be restricted to daytime hours.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned Mr. Hammack regarding how much
time will lapse before it goes into production? Mr. Hammack replied
immediately upon completion.
City of Col/eyville Page 5 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final November 9, 2009
Commissioner Phelps questioned Mr. Hammack regarding if there is
anything else that is visual as opposed to noise oriented during this
production. Mr. Hammack replied the drilling rig would be seen. He
stated in the event of an emergency, there could be flaring seen, but
only in the event of an emergency.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned Mr. Head regarding what type of
flexibility do you want regarding the sound? Mr. Head stated there are a
few specifications on the muffler systems which would consist of hospital
grade systems. He stated there can be blankets or rubber mats on
substructures to eliminate the sound. He stated sound walls can be
interior, right up against the area, not just around the pad site. He stated
there are several options that could be considered, which a sound
engineer could recommend. He stated a 28 foot sound wall may not do
what you, the city, want it to do.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned Mr. Hammack regarding the chain
link fencing would be up for 90 days, however, when would you install
the masonry fencing? Mr. Hammack replied the chain link fencing is for
security and it contains screening. He stated once the drilling operations
are complete, when all the wells on the site are complete, the masonry
wall would be installed. Commissioner Dudziak stated that could be
seven years from now. Mr. Hammack concurred, however if the
Commissioners would like for the wall to be installed before, we could.
Commissioner Phelps questioned staff regarding if the wall is to be
installed at the completion of first well or the completion of production?
Ron Ruthven replied the ordinance reads prior to the production phase
the wall shall be installed. Commissioner Phelps stated that would
indicate 30 days. Mr. Hammack agreed.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned Mr. Head regarding if the concrete
drive would remain in place until all of the well structures have been
complete? Mr. Head replied not necessarily. He stated if a developer
comes in before the drilling is complete, then the drive could be moved
through the fabric of the development. He stated it would be at the
expense of the developer to move the driveway.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned Mr. Head regarding if they want to do
the landscape planting at the completion of the wells? Mr. Head replied
upon completion of those wells, and after they are producing, the
landscaping would be installed.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned Mr. Hammack regarding what type
of lighting is required? Mr. Hammack replied there is lighting along the
drilling rig itself for safety issues. He stated they use amber lighting, very
low wattage and beacons at the top for aviation.
City of Colleyville Page 6 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final
November 9, 2009
Commissioner Redfearn questioned Mr. Hammack regarding if there is
any lighting on the site itself? Mr. Hammack replied the rig itself has
illumination, base of the rig and around the rig to be able to work safely.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned Mr. Hammack regarding if there will
be lighting on the access road from Pleasant Run Road? Mr. Hammack
replied there will be no lighting on the access road.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned Mr. Hammack regarding if there is
any air testing done by Titan, initially to get a base sampling to have
some standards to judge any changes by? Mr. Hammack stated they
will in this case to have some type of base line.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned Mr. Hammack regarding if there are
some things that you will test for or are recommended to be tested for
when developing a natural gas well? Mr. Hammack replied they will
need to refer to an environmental scientist, expert, to evaluate the
situation.
Commissioner Dudziak opened the public hearing at 8:20 p.m.
Chuck Sledge, 7317 Cedar Court, Colleyville, stated being in support of
the request.
Louis Miller, 7802 Tillman Hill Court, Colleyville, stated being in support
of the request.
Grady Walker, 7309 John McCain, Colleyville, stated being in support of
the request.
Mark Griffin, 803 Potomac Place, Southlake, stated being in support of
the request but stated having concerns about the notification of this
request. He stated most drilling sites are exempt from most of the EPA
standards. He stated he would like the operator to be held to the utmost
of standards in the ordinance. He wants them to live up to the letter of
the law.
Richard Lyon, 115 Creekway Bend, Southlake, spoke in opposition to
the request and stated having concerns for the marketability of his home.
Frances Gaver, 309 Oak Crest Hill Drive, Colleyville, spoke in opposition
to the request and stated having concerns for the toxins in the air.
Jennifer Kessmann, 711 Greymoor Place, Southlake, spoke in
opposition to the request and stated having concerns for the air quality.
She stated the 1,000 foot standard should be in place for both Colleyville
and the Southlake residents.
City of Colleyville Page 7 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final
November 9, 2009
David Fink, 6400 Ponderosa Lane, Colleyville, stated having concerns
for the traffic route to be used.
Jeff Wall, 7900 Jefferson Circle, Colleyville, stated the site was not
picked when they signed the lease.
Cyndi Miller, 7112 Pleasant Run Road, Colleyville, spoke in support of
the drilling but the quality of air needs to be of primary concern before,
during and after. She also stated having concerns for the new round
about the city is proposing at John McCain and Pleasant Run Road.
AI Zito, 501 Potomac Place, Southlake, spoke in opposition to the
request with concerns to resale value.
Susan Brown, 400 Latrobe Court, Southlake, spoke in opposition to the
request with concerns to the air quality.
Lynn Buffington, 1400 S. White Chapel, Southlake, spoke in opposition
to the request with concerns to property value, safety, security.
Michael DeNicola, 1680 Bent Creek Drive, Southlake, spoke in
opposition to the request with concerns for the location of the site.
Shawn McCaskill, 601 Potomac Place, Southlake, spoke in opposition to
the request with concerns for the air quality.
Claire Lopez, 701 Beverly Drive, Colleyville, spoke in support of the
request.
Kevin Townson, 175 Creekway Bend, Southlake, spoke in opposition to
the request with concerns to traffic and pollution.
Beth Adams, 165 Creekway Bend, Southlake, spoke in opposition to the
request with concerns to the health impact.
James Kniese, 6512 Pondersa Lane, Colleyville, spoke in support of the
request providing all of the concerns are addressed.
Michael Burns, 105 Creekway Bend, Southlake, spoke in opposition to
the request with concerns for resale value.
James Day, 805 Shelton Drive, Colleyville, spoke in favor of the request.
David Young, 509 Potomac Place, Southlake, spoke in opposition to the
request and stated they were not told as to where the site would be and
stated having concerns for resale value. He stated Titan should hold
City of Colleyville Page 8 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final
November 9, 2009
true to their contract.
David Ray, 1640 Bent Creek Drive, Southlake, spoke in opposition to the
request with regards to the 1,000 foot setback and health concerns.
AI Zito, Monticello HOA, spoke in opposition to the request with regards
to concerns for the breach of contract with Titan. He stated Titan stated
they would not put a site within 1,000 feet of any HOA land.
There being no one wishing to speak, the public hearing was closed at
9:15 p.m.
Mr. Hammack and Mr. Head came forward to answer any questions. Mr.
Head stated he feels their application has addressed all of the issues
and concerns of the neighbors. He stated there is no evidence that a
well site will hurt the resale values of homes. He stated staff has
adequately addressed the concerns of the testing of air quality. He
stated this city is the first city that has addressed the issues of air quality
in the Barnett Shale and Titan is willing to comply with TCEQ and the
EPA regarding air quality issues.
Commissioner Phelps questioned Mr. Head regarding if they are willing
to address any traffic route or intersection improvements while this site is
in production? Mr. Head stated this route was actually the best route out
of the 4 or 5 options. Commissioner Phelps questioned Mr. Head
regarding if the costs of the intersection improvements will be taken on
by Titan? Mr. Head replied Titan is willing to look at all options of
improvements if issues arise along the way.
Commissioner Phelps questioned Mr. Hammack regarding what are the
parallels or lack of parallels regarding this site and the Dish, Texas
situation? Mr. Hammack replied these are different situations. He
stated these emissions at the Dish, Texas site, are being generated by a
compression system, however, this site, on Pleasant Run, is not going to
be a transmission site, it is going to be an oil and gas well site. He
stated they are very different.
Commissioner Rotthaus questioned Mr. Hammack regarding what are
the water impacts? Mr. Hammack stated the water is regulated by
TCEQ and they have applied to TCEQ for a water permit. He stated this
will be 200 feet below the fresh water system. He also explained to the
Commission the construction regarding the water system, piping and
tubing systems. He stated these are very highly regulated by TCEQ and
they have measures in place to monitor situations.
Commissioner Clardy questioned Mr. Hammack regarding as far as the
water needed for each well and fracturing process, how will the water be
City of Colleyville Page 9 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final November 9, 2009
extracted? Mr. Hammack replied the water will be purchased from the
city. He stated if the city shuts down because of a drought, the water
well is used in case the water can not be retrieved from the city. Mr.
Head stated they are requesting 350 gallons per minute from one of the
fire hydrants on the frontage of the property. He stated they will work
with city staff regarding the withdrawal rate so that nobody is impacted
along the way. He stated the water well is just needed in case they can
not get water from the city. Mr. Hammack stated any water wells drilled
on the site would be directly drilled to the Trinity water system, around 12
or 1500 feet.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned Mr. Hammack regarding if the State
or TCEQ will do a before test to make sure the water tables are
protected? Mr. Hammack stated they do determine the usable level of
quality depths are. He stated not knowing how they determine the depth
of usable levels of water.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned Mr. Hammack if there are other
organic compounds currently in the air that could harm the residents?
Mr. Hammack replied no, not in their opinion. He stated the gas in the
Barnett Shale is a very dry lean gas, not a lot of impurities. He stated
the gas being extracted is the same gas used in homes.
Commissioner Dudziak stated they are the first city to ask for air quality
standards. Mr. Head concurred; he stated no other city has required air
testing.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned Mr. Hammack regarding if there are
any exemptions that regulating agencies can opt out of environmental
enforcements? Mr. Hammack stated he is not aware of any.
Commissioner Redfearn stated EPA and State. Mr. Hammack
concurred.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned Mr. Hammack regarding what is the
logic of needing the setback in the first place? Mr. Hammack replied
International Fire Code governs it at 200 feet to a structure applied
outside the municipalities.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned Mr. Hammack regarding if 1,000
feet is common in municipalities? Mr. Hammack replied they vary,
anywhere from 200 feet to up to the strictest being 1,000 feet.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned Mr. Hammack regarding what is the
time line that the derrick will be in the air, when are you going to start?
Mr. Hammack replied the rig will not be in the air for 7 years. He stated
there could be a total of 13 months total, in other words up for 2 to 4
months in the air, gone for 6 months and back for a few more months in
City of Colleyville Page 10 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final
November 9, 2009
the air. He stated all activities are masked behind the wall and foliage.
He stated this site is limited from view because of the foliage.
Commissioner Clardy questioned Mr. Hammack how will the issue
regarding the 1,000 foot setback be addressed with the Monticello HOA.
Mr. Hammack replied they became aware of the situation late last week
and he stated they try to work with all of the residents. He stated the
location of this well site was known by all.
Commissioner Rotthaus questioned staff regarding the public display of
the test results, how will that be done? Ron Ruthven replied it can be
added to the draft ordinance as part of the inspectors evaluation or
testing of the air is to publish those results.
Commissioner Phelps commended staff regarding the work put forth in
this ordinance. However, he stated there are some wrinkles within
Chapter 3.1 that were not anticipated. He stated having concerns for
future development within the 1,000 foot radius. He stated he would like
to further understand what the consequences are of failed test. Ron
Ruthven stated if a home were to be built within the 1,000 feet, the
ordinance would not prohibit that. He stated as a condition of the SUP,
for future homes, parameters could be established for around this site.
He stated if air quality testing should be at levels not acceptable by
standards, all gas operations would cease until the source of air quality
violation is identified. Commissioner Phelps questioned staff regarding
who would be the enforcer for the stopping of the gas operations? Ron
Ruthven replied the inspector would have to notify the city and the city
would issue the stop work order.
Commissioner Phelps questioned staff regarding what are the plans for a
roundabout at John McCain and Pleasant Run Road and what are the
plans for working with the truck traffic when construction begins? Senior
Project Engineer stated the design and engineering will begin in 2010
and construction will proceed in 2011. He stated they have taken into
consideration and will incorporate the design with the truck route in mind.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned staff regarding will this SUP ever
expire or run out? Ron Ruthven replied either at 6 months with an
abandonment of the well or upon cessation of production where the
wells are capped and brought back to the original condition.
Commissioner Redfearn questioned staff if a condition can be put in this
SUP that affects a property other than the subject property? In other
words, new construction within so many feet of the well site? Ron
Ruthven replied yes, especially if within 1,000 feet of the subject property
owner. Ron Ruthven stated his recommendation to the Commission
would be, that if you want to establish a buffer, maybe a no build buffer,
City of Colleyvil/e Page 11 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final November 9, 2009
around the well site, it would probably be best to keep it at least a few
hundred feet or on the subject property itself.
Commissioner Phelps stated having a procedural concern with looking at
a SUP with a 1,000 foot radius yet having a notification area that goes by
the standard 200 foot. He stated not knowing if that would require a
change in city policy rather than in proximity of the property being zoned
but within the impacted area. In this instance, notification should be
1,000 feet. He stated he would like a better understanding of what is
developable on this property.
Commissioner Dudziak questioned staff regarding what are the
standards for the third party inspector? Rob McKeown stated not
knowing at this time. He stated he will look for someone who had
worked in other cities to see what the process was used. Commissioner
Dudziak stated we are the first city to have the air quality testing
requirement. He questioned staff regarding how are you going to be
able to use another example if other cities have not required this? Rob
McKeown stated gas wells are all over the state of Texas and are
inspected everyday. He stated there are bound to be some standards as
to what should be measured.
Commissioner Dudziak stated testing upon commencement does not
give us a baseline. He stated not being comfortable with the one mile
radius of the drill site. He stated wanting the proper area to be tested to
safeguard the residents. He stated there are some issues that need to
be addressed before moving forward. Ron Ruthven stated the applicant
was willing to have a consultant to get those air quality standards,
industry standards. He stated there are no city laws regarding these
standards, these are state and federal laws that govern those standards.
He stated the baselines are already in place set forth by the state. He
stated an expert on air quality for best testing measures can be
consulted.
Commissioner Redfearn stated there may be a gap between where they
are and where we want to be. We may want to have more rigorous
standards in place. He stated environmental concerns were of utmost
concern of the citizens.
Commissioner Dudziak stated the frequent measurements would need to
be known going in so that Titan will know what they are working with. He
stated having a concern for the drilling company to do the hiring of the
third party inspectors and paying them for the inspections.
Commissioner Phelps discussed issues he had regarding the letter the
applicant presented before the meeting.
City of Colleyville Page 12 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final November 9, 2009
Commissioner Phelps moved to table case ZC09-011. Commissioner
Clardy seconded.
Commissioner Dudziak concurred.
The motion carried by the following vote:
Aye: 5 -Dudziak, Redfearn, Clardy, Rotthaus, Phelps
Excused: 2 -Knox, Byerly
Cify of Colleyvil/e Page 13 Printed on 11/24/2009
Planning and Zoning Commission Minutes -Final November 9, 2009
8. TABLED AGENDA ITEMS
8a Approval of a request for a zoning change from CC1-Village Retail,
ML-Light Manufacturing and PUDC-Planned Unit Development
Commercial to PUDC-Planned Unit Development Commercial on Lot
R-14-2 in the Colleyville Industrial Park Addition and 1.4 acres located at
6401 and 6405 Colleyville Boulevard, Case ZC09-010
The applicant was not ready for this item to be removed from the table
therefore the Commission did not open this item for discussion.
9. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 10:07 p.m
I hereby certify the above agenda was posted on the bulletin boards at City Hall
on Thursday, November 5, 2009 by 5:00 p.m.
Amy Shelley, Planning and Zoning Assistant
The meeting minutes were approved on November 23, 2009.
City of Colleyville Page 14 Printed on 11/24/2009